[SIPForum-techwg] SIPconnect/1.1 v03 onlist - section 7 support for registration

[Spencer Dawkins]

(Just a word of administrivia - we had some topics at last Friday's telechat that we said needed to be discussed onlist - I'll be posting a few of these today)

Current text in Section 7 says:

The required support for each mode is shown in Table 1.

 

      Mode
     Registration
     Static
     
      SIP-PBX
     MUST support
     MAY support
     
      SP-SSE
     MUST support
     MUST support
     

Table 1: Required Support for SIPconnect/1.1 Modes

 

Spencer: Alan has challenged Registration at MUST level for all SIP-PBXes, regardless of size. His concern makes sense to me. Comments? Need to discuss onlist (did not come to consensus on telechat) on next telechat.



Obviously, we didn't come to agreement on last Friday's telechat, and we've been discussing onlist, but I wanted to put the discussions in terms of the current text.

>From the editor's perspective, what's in question is the MUST for the SIP-PBX to support Registration mode. Our choices are MUST, SHOULD (probably with an escape hatch based on size), and MAY.

What should Table 1 say in this cell?

Thanks,

SPencer
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://sipforum.org/pipermail/techwg/attachments/20090204/ea6329d0/attachment.html