[Smartgrid] Minutes of meeting of our first call (Oct 2 2009)
shidan at gulfpearl.com
Mon Nov 2 18:28:21 EST 2009
I think you have covered it, also this thread is interesting from the
concern is if their is really a need for a whole new protocol to evolve or
if it's reinventing the wheel.
On Mon, Nov 2, 2009 at 4:56 PM, Arjun Roychowdhury <arjun.lists at hsc.com>wrote:
> Here is as best as I can remember - please add if I missed something.
> Joe Di Adamo, Siemens Enterprise
> Henning Schulzrinne, Columbia Univ
> Shidan Gouran, Home Jini
> Mark Enstrom, Neustar
> Arjun Roychowdhury, Hughes Systique
> Items discussed
> 1. There is a need for this group to come out with a technical paper on
> why SIP is applicable to the smart grid space and what benefits it brings in
> (The only paper we have right now is the one Joe wrote and our recent I-D
> but we need more details)
> 2. For each vertical (example HAN, NAN, core, PEV) within the smartgrid
> space that SIP applies to, the paper should clearly state:
> 1. What are the constraints (if any) wrt
> size/performance/latency/reliability of that vertical and does SIP meet
> 2. What are the 'minimal must have' requirements and does SIP meet
> 3. What extra benefits does SIP bring in?
> 3. There was a discussion on the current 6lowapp charter - some of the
> current sipforum smartgrid folks have also chipped into discussion threads,
> but it is not clear yet what is the real problem that group is trying to
> solve. The 6lowapp thread is here:
> 4. The participants were of the feeling that the benefits of SIP come
> out strongly when looked at an end-end network perspective. If one were to
> only focus on one vertical, its hard to justify any protocol beyond an
> existing one (as technically, any protocol can morph)
> Action Items
> 1. Henning to get in touch with some folks @ 6lowapp to better
> understand the constrained devices they are trying to cater to.
> 2. Mark will look at speaking with Eric on talking about some of the
> benefits of SIP @ the current IETF from a sipforum perspective
> 3. Joe will be sending out a TOC on the whitepaper and work will be
> distributed accordingly
> I think we need to get this whitepaper out by latest Nov. end - comments
> welcome if thoughts differ on this.
> Arjun Roychowdhury
> Smartgrid mailing list
> Smartgrid at sipforum.org
President & CEO, Gulf Pearl Ltd.
Suite 2200, 4950 Yonge Street
Toronto, ON M2N 6K1
shidan at gulfpearl.com
Office: (416) 218-5583
Cell: (416) 854-3017
Fax: (416) 221-4668
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Smartgrid